Loading…

Vansh Patel on Smuckers vs Trader Joes

Vansh Patel

Smuckers vs Trader Joes

Claims and stances

0:00 Vansh Patel strongly supports: Trader Joe's business model relies on offering private-label products that are functionally similar to major national brands.
1:10 Vansh Patel strongly supports: The survival of smaller brands depends on whether the prestige and status associated with a logo can outweigh the consumer's desire for lower-priced, functionally identical alternatives.
2:01 Vansh Patel strongly supports: Rising financial pressures in the US will drive a large-scale consumer transition toward private-label products from large corporations because many consumers can no longer afford name-brand goods.
2:26 Vansh Patel supports: The current state of late-stage capitalism makes it unlikely that the government will implement mandates to prevent the formation of corporate monopolies.

Transcript

0:00 Luca, I think you brought up an excellent point on how s smaller companies such as Smunkers are suing their larger uh counterparts such as Trader Joe's for replicating their products and selling them for most likely a cheaper uh price.
0:17 Uh I wanted to bring up the point that it's not just the snack market that's doing this.
0:21 You look at companies like Kirkland Signature from uh from Costco, they recently got in trouble I know for their wedges.
0:29 I I think for replicating, I forget the brand, but I think Taylor Made or Mizuno wedges, uh they replicated the exact same product for almost half the price.
0:41 And I know this goes on with many more products.
0:44 I know their sodas, their their liquor for certain uh Kirkland vodka, some of their things like that.
0:51 These bigger companies such as Costco, Sam's Club, Trader Joe's are able to replicate these products with almost the exact same taste and possibly even more quality for a lower price.
1:06 So I'm interested to see how that progresses in the market.
1:10 Are these smaller companies gonna die out eventually for charging some of these outrageous prices or is the prestige around the price still gonna keep these companies afloat?
1:21 Because I know a big thing in the US is the prestige of the companies.
1:26 I mean that's the reason designer brands are alive today is because prestige definitely matters.
1:32 I think a logo matters in the eye of the American public, uh people want to be represented well and people want to be represented in a high standard and I'm interested to see if this will uh keep some of these smaller companies alive.
1:47 But when it comes to the snack market, I'm not sure much sir, uh sure so because at the end of the day, uh if the products are the same, the branding of the food is not a big concern to many.
2:01 Uh especially as financial issues continue to rise uh in the US, people aren't being able to afford groceries.
2:10 Uh I think you'll see a large transition to these bigger corporations and their products rather than these smaller companies.
2:19 I mean, most people can't afford name brand Oreos, but I'm sure they can afford the larger company counterpart.
2:26 Uh I'm interested also interested to see if the government will have any effect in this.
2:33 Uh as we are in late-stage capitalism, we're only on the rise of monopolies in this nation.
2:39 So I'm interested to see if there would be any mandates that are able to stop some of these monopolies from forming.
2:46 But uh as of now I do doubt it.
2:49 So yeah, I think you brought up an excellent topic that needs to be addressed.